The EV Tax Debate: Should Electric Vehicle Owners Pay More to Use the Roads?
As electric vehicle (EV) adoption accelerates across the U.S., states are grappling with a major funding dilemma: how to replace the billions of dollars traditionally generated by gasoline taxes, which have long funded infrastructure and road maintenance. Since EVs don’t use gasoline, their owners don’t contribute to these taxes, leading states to explore alternative revenue models—most notably, additional EV registration fees.
How Gas Taxes Fund Roads—and Why EVs Are a Problem
For decades, gasoline taxes have served as the primary funding source for road repairs and infrastructure projects. In 2022, the federal gas tax generated about $36 billion, with state fuel taxes adding billions more. However, as EVs grow in popularity, this funding model is being disrupted.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, EVs now account for about 10% of new car sales and could make up as many as 40% of all vehicles by 2030. That’s a significant number of drivers who are no longer contributing to road upkeep through gas taxes, prompting many states to impose new EV-specific fees.
"We have to think long-term about how we're going to maintain our roads," said Susan Howard, director of policy and government relations for the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO). "As gas tax revenues decline, we need a sustainable alternative that ensures fairness for all drivers."
State-By-State EV Fees
So far, 39 states have implemented additional annual registration fees for EVs, ranging from $50 to over $250 per year. Here’s how some states are handling the issue, according to NCSL:
Georgia: Charges non-commercial EV owners $200 per year and commercial EV owners $300 annually.
Indiana: Raised its annual EV fee to $221 in 2023 to offset declining gas tax revenue. Hybrid fees increased to $74.
Texas: Imposed a $400 annual EV fee for newly registered vehicles and a $200 charge for subsequent years.
Utah: The state charges a $138.50 additional annual fee for EVs and vehicles fueled by a source other than motor fuel, diesel fuel, natural gas or propane. There is also a $60.25 additional annual fee for plug-in hybrid EVs and a $23.25 charge for hybrid EVs.
Ohio: Ohio has a categorized approach, charging annual fees of $200 for battery electric motor vehicles, $150 for plug-in hybrids, and $100 for traditional hybrid automobiles.
West Virginia: The state imposes a $200 annual fee on EVs and a $100 fee on hybrid vehicles.
Wyoming: Plug-in electric vehicle owners pay an annual flat fee of $200.
Missouri: Missouri charges a $120 additional annual fuel decal fee for alternative-fueled passenger motor vehicles up to 18,000 lbs and a $60 additional annual fee for plug-in electric hybrid vehicles.
Illinois: The state charges an annual $100 flat fee for electric vehicle registration.
Kentucky: As of January 2024, Kentucky has imposed a $120 registration fee for electric vehicles and a $60 fee for hybrid automobiles.
Kansas: All-electric motor vehicle owners are required to pay a $100 annual registration fee, while electric hybrid and plug-in hybrid vehicle owners pay $50.
North Carolina: The state imposes an annual registration fee of $180 for electric vehicles and a $90 annual fee for plug-in hybrids.
Alabama: EV owners are subject to a $200 annual registration fee, with an additional $100 fee for plug-in hybrid vehicles.
The state of Oklahoma has one of the most interesting approaches, charging EV owners by the weight of their automobile:
Under 6000 lbs. (Class 1) - $110
6000 - 10000 lbs. (Class 2) - $158
10000 - 26000 lbs. (Class 3-6) - $363
Over 26000 lbs. (Class 7-8) - $2250
The annual fee for plug-in hybrids is dependent upon weight:
Under 6000 lbs. (Class 1) - $82
6000 - 10000 lbs. (Class 2) - $118
10000 - 26000 lbs. (Class 3-6) - $272
Over 26000 lbs. (Class 7-8) - $1687
In some states, these fees can be nearly triple what the average gasoline driver pays in fuel taxes per year. Critics argue this unfairly penalizes EV owners, while proponents say it's a necessary measure to ensure all road users contribute fairly.
The Pushback: Are EV Fees Discouraging Green Adoption?
Consumer and environmental advocacy groups worry that these extra costs could discourage EV adoption, undermining climate goals and slowing the transition away from fossil fuels.
"The unintended consequence is that we're taxing the very people who are helping reduce emissions," said Katherine Garcia, director of the Clean Transportation for All campaign at the Sierra Club. "Instead of imposing high fees, we should be incentivizing clean energy solutions."
A 2019 Consumer Reports study found that many of these state EV fees exceed what the average gasoline-powered car owner pays in gas taxes. This could disincentivize drivers from switching to electric, making it harder to meet the Biden administration’s goal of having 50% of new car sales be electric by 2030.
The Federal Perspective: Biden vs. Trump on EV Policies
At the federal level, President Joe Biden’s administration strongly backed EV tax credits and infrastructure investments, aiming to make electric vehicles more accessible to middle- and lower-income Americans. The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 provided up to $7,500 in tax credits for new EV purchases and up to $4,000 for qualifying used EV purchases, and tied incentives to domestic battery production.
However, sitting President Donald Trump, who is currently serving his second, non-consecutive term in office, has vowed to repeal many EV-related incentives, arguing that they hurt traditional automakers and unfairly favor companies like Tesla. His administration has also pushed back against federal mandates on EV production quotas, which could directly impact the tax structure for these vehicles.
"Democrats are trying to force-feed…drivers expensive electrical vehicles – vehicles that we don’t need, want, and most families can’t afford,” said Senator John Barrasso (R-WY), a vocal critic of Biden's EV policies.
Alternative Solutions: What’s Next?
Rather than imposing flat fees, some policymakers are exploring alternative ways to make up for lost gas tax revenue. These include:
1. Mileage-Based User Fees (MBUF)
Also known as "road usage charges," this model would tax drivers based on miles driven, rather than fuel consumption. States like Oregon and Utah have pilot programs testing this system.
2. EV-Specific Tolls
Certain highways could introduce higher tolls for EVs, ensuring that they contribute to road maintenance without discouraging adoption.
3. Corporate Contributions
Some policymakers suggest requiring automakers to contribute a percentage of EV sales revenue toward infrastructure maintenance.
Nick Smallwood, chief executive of the Infrastructure and Projects Authority, shared an alternative option – road pricing – with The Guardian:
"We need to consider how we replace fuel duty as we move towards electric vehicles. Road pricing is one option that could provide a sustainable long-term solution."
While Smallwood was specifically referring to the United Kingdom, road pricing – a system of fees including tolls, congestion charges, and other costs – is already used in the United States. Expanded toll roads, for instance, could help states recoup money lost from increased EV usage.
As states continue to tweak their revenue models, the debate over EV fees vs. gas taxes will only intensify. With EV adoption growing rapidly, finding a fair and effective way to fund infrastructure is crucial.
For now, EV owners in most states should expect to pay additional fees, but the exact amount—and whether it remains fair—will likely remain a hot-button issue for years to come.
More About Us
Get to Know Prestige Accounting Services Group
Offices in Flemington, NJ, and Califon, NJ
Our Mission: At Prestige Accounting Services Group, we are on a mission to redefine the tax experience for individuals and small businesses. With a focus on personalized service, strategic planning, and expert guidance, we aim to empower our clients to succeed financially with confidence and ease.
Expertise in Action: With a wealth of experience and a team of dedicated professionals, we specialize in individual and small business tax preparation. While we excel in all areas of taxation, our passion lies in serving the unique needs of small business owners in New Jersey. We understand that small business taxation requires specialized knowledge and attention to detail, which is why we go above and beyond to ensure our clients receive the guidance and support they deserve.
Tailored Solutions for Every Client: Whether you're a high-net-worth individual seeking comprehensive tax planning or a small business owner in need of accounting and bookkeeping assistance, we have the expertise to meet your needs. Our team takes the time to understand your specific situation and develop customized solutions that align with your goals and objectives.
Why Choose Us?: What sets us apart from other New Jersey tax firms is our commitment to excellence and innovation in the field of taxation. We don't just prepare tax returns; we provide strategic insights, proactive planning, and actionable advice to help our clients achieve their financial goals. With a team of two CPAs, an EA, and an ERO, we have the expertise and resources to deliver exceptional service and results.
Your Success is Our Priority: At Prestige Accounting Services Group, we measure our success by the success of our clients. We are dedicated to building long-lasting relationships, providing unparalleled service, and helping our clients thrive in today's ever-changing tax landscape.
We can't wait for you to experience the Prestige Accounting Services Group difference.
Tax & Small Business Updates
Get the latest in tax and small business updates and issues that affect your finances and growth prospects.